Messiah

Messiah

by George Handel

December 14, 2008

Somewhere in the Salt Lake City, Utah area...

This is my first negative review, but to be honest, I didn't find much to be positive about with this particular production. Let me say this; I almost left two measures into the overture. There's not much worse than listening in the first violins play flat. Well, I guess, at least they were consistent. (Imagine me rolling my eyes at this point...)

I almost left, it was so bad. Than I thought, well I might as well stay so I can write a review about it. So, I suffered through it. Wishing I had ear plugs throughout most of it.

This production was presented by several churches in the area (due to the negativeness of this review I have opted to leave out any direct reference to the locale, the church(es), the soloists. In part, because I'll most likely join the choir and audition for a solo for the next year's production. I'll comment more on that later.).

The soloists were picked from the chorus. That has an advantage, but personally, I want to hear a soloist. I takes time for the soloists to step out of the choir sits and go to the place to sing their aria. Which only adds to the, well for lack of a better word, uncomfortableness of the event.

As with the Messiah Sing-In I participated in a couple weeks previous, this group did highlights of the complete work. Just once, I'd like to go to a presentation of Messiah and hear the complete work. With orchestra of course. And live. Sure, I can listen to the complete work on CD, but hearing it live is SO much better. I digress, back to the topic at hand.

SC, a high school student, sang "Comfort ye, my people." You know, I'm just going to leave it at that. He's a high school student. DL - "Every valley shall be exalted." In my notes I wrote, "Oh my ears!" DL was also the timpanist for the orchestra. The timpani sounded wonderful. Than the chorus sang, "And the glory of the Lord shall be revealed." They lacked any and all emotion.

"Thus saith the Lord, the Lord of Hosts," in my score is listed as a baritone number. Um, RC is a tenor. He tried to sound like a baritone. I get that sometimes in these types of productions you have to have tenors sing baritone roles to fill in, as it where, for parts where you don't actually have a decent baritone. But a note to the tenor filling such a part, DON'T TRY TO SOUND LIKE A FREAKING BARITONE! Another comment about DL and RC, they both breathed at the end of EVERY MEASURE! I get that sometimes you need to breath during those long phrases in "Every valley," but not every measure.

"O thou that tellest good tidings to Zion" was sung by JA. I kinda wish she had stuck to choral singing. Another note about each of the soloists up to this point, none of them looked out of their music for more than half a second, except to look at the conductor. DN sang the recitatives (numbers 14-16) leading up to the chorus number "Glory to God" (Number 17). She did a good job at it, except the high note at the end of 16, "And suddenly there was with the angel." This good be attributed to nerves. I'm going to be nice for a moment and give her the benefit of the doubt. During "Glory to God," I received a bonus. The violins weren't playing flat. Woot Hoot! I was happy.

HM sang "Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion." She has a nice sound on the sustained notes, though her voice is whiny at times. The top of her voice was nice, but the bottom seemed to "fall out" of her voice and she sounded unsupported on the lower notes. Again, could be due to nerves...(I'm trying to end my mean streak...Okay, not really.) Than the orchestra hurt me again in number 20 during "Come unto Him."

Number 23, "He was despised and rejected." Ms. TO, (this is taken directly from my notes) Wow a contralto. She wasn't flat at all. She looked up from her music. What is she doing here? The chorus number (Number 33) "Lift up your heads, O ye gates" wasn't bad at all. DW sang, "why do the nations so furiously rage together?" He has a nice bottom, the top isn't so good and the middle is kinda spread. He sings with lots of tension. (By the way, I'm talking about his voice, NOT his physical attributes.)

I was glad to see that the audience respected the tradition of standing during "Hallelujah!" I didnt' want to be the only one. That would've been awkward.

"I know that my Redeemer liveth" was sung by Ms. TR. She has a pleasant voice. Not really screechy, but a little more "airy" than I prefer. But than, I'll take airy over screechy anyday. "Dang you orchestra!"

Mr. DW, who also sang "Why do the nations so furiously rage together?" also sang "The trumpet shall sound." The same problems presented themselves with this aria as well. He was slightly under pitch on the high notes, it's probably technique issues, though I'm not qualified to say much in that regard. But reading his bio included in the program, one would think he'd have done a better job than he did. By the way, the trumpet solo, was flawless. And wouldn't you know, the violins were conspiring against me.

The final movement, number 53, "Worthy is the Lamb that was slain" is difficult to sing. Okay, so it's not terribly difficult until the "Amen" section. I felt sorry for the soprano, who kept getting lost and looking over to the soprano next to her trying to figure out what page they were on. I think at that point, I would've made up my own part and sang whatever note I heard in the orchestra.

As I was leaving the hall I updated my facebook status via text to say, "Joey didn't think it possible to ruin Handel's Messiah." One of my friends commented back saying, "you mean you didn't think it was possible and someone did?" "Yes," I replied. "Maybe you're just too picky." And maybe I am, but that's life. We get over it eventually.